I obviously have a lot of THOUGHTS and FEELINGS on bikinis
and modesty. For now, however, I want to stick with criticizing the original
piece that started this year’s modesty shitstorm. I realize that at this point,
I’m writing two months after the original article. Sorry, y’all, but I am not
paid to blog, and as much as I love writing, I love writing well even more, which means that it
takes time to organize all my thoughts coherently.
I mentioned a shitstorm, right? Yeah, the evangelical and/or
feminist blogosphere has gone crazy this summer (like it does every summer…)
talking about bikinis and modesty. Although each voice is slightly different,
on both sides of the argument, I see one common theme throughout the
pro-modesty bloggers/commenters, one that is present in the original post.
So why don’t you just wear a bikini, you ask? Why? Because I am making a sacrifice for the guys around me. I’ve heard the excuse, Guys just have an imagination, it’s not a girl’s problem. Frankly, I think that’s stupid. Part of it is our problem. The way we dress impacts those around us, especially guys. I don’t really want a guy to look at me and notice me for my butt, upper thighs, or chest. I’d rather him notice my smile or God-loving personality. Well sure, you say, that’s all fine and good, but guys should be able to control their imagination and look beyond our bodies. That’s true, they should control it. But it’s important for girls to help them as they try and do so…
This is how I imagine it is for guys. Girls are walking around all the time with barely any clothes on at the beach or pool! Guys can never get a break from it, even if they’re trying to see past all the bodies to find the smiles and personalities within the girls.
So really, how hard is it to not wear a bikini? If you’re like me, it might be a little disappointing... Let’s make a commitment this summer to ditch the skimpy swimsuits, earn self respect, and help our brothers in Christ.
The original article never refers to scripture, but the
comments and other blogs are all quick to quote Romans 14 as justification for
women covering up their bodies. The overall message is: Yes, men are
responsible for their own lust, but women need to help them out by covering up.
Seriously, if one more person tells me I’m a “stumbling
block” for men, I’ll give up clothes forever and join a nudist colony.
Let’s examine Romans 14 together. The entire chapter is
relevant, so you should pull that up in a separate window. I’m just going to
quote the part that is popular on the Interwebz.
Romans 14: 20-21 (NRSV) 20 Do not, for the sake of food,
destroy the work of God. Everything is indeed clean, but it is wrong for you to
make others fall by what you eat; 21 it is good not to eat meat or drink wine
or do anything that makes your brother or sister stumble.
One more common point by the pro-modesty crowd. Many of them
offer the analogy of an alcoholic. Would you serve alcohol to your friend who’s
a recovering alcoholic? No, because you don’t want to tempt him to sin, even if
drinking alcohol isn’t sinful for you.
| Should I give up champagne forever just in case I run into an alcoholic? |
The original bikini post, the horrible misinterpretation of
Romans 14, and the alcoholic analogy all share a fatal flaw:






